Issues

• [ROAST][MINOR] Related work: RLCD dibahas panjang padahal tidak dipakai; baseline klasik intent detection absen

  roastseverity: minor
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#28 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026

• [ROAST][MINOR] Statistik: tidak ada uji signifikansi, tidak ada std, 3 seed untuk klaim seed-variance

  roastseverity: minor
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#27 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026

• [ROAST][MINOR] Format & venue berantakan: header IJACSA di IEEEtran, placeholder, dua .tex divergen, binary di-commit

  roastseverity: minor
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#26 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026

• [ROAST][MAJOR] Tidak ada figure sama sekali; Algorithm 1 bukan algoritma

  roastseverity: major
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#25 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026
  2

• [ROAST][MAJOR] Paraphrase grid: "3-variant" vs "2 variants", typed tidak diparafrase, seed runs kosong

  roastseverity: major
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#23 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026
  1

• [ROAST][MAJOR] Klaim efisiensi/latency tidak pernah dibandingkan; "no KV-cache growth" tidak diukur

  roastseverity: major
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#21 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026
  3

• [ROAST][MAJOR] Calibration set ~136 item untuk fit multi-temperature + cross-fitting = noise

  roastseverity: major
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#19 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026
  1

• [ROAST][MAJOR] "Capacity frontier: architectural capacity, not recipe" — klaim tanpa eksperimen

  roastseverity: major
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#16 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026

• [ROAST][MAJOR] Novelty tipis: head-nya "attached by default" oleh Unsloth, klaim hybrid tidak diuji

  roastseverity: major
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#15 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026

• [ROAST][MAJOR] Akuntansi data tidak konsisten: 13 vs 15 sumber, 30k vs 28k vs 43k

  roastseverity: major
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#14 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026
  2

• [ROAST][MAJOR] Test set non-standar (subset 500) dan unit hitung yang tidak konsisten

  roastseverity: major
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#13 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026
  1

• [ROAST][CRITICAL] "License text is still unread" tertulis di naskah + klaim reproducibility kosong

  roastseverity: critical
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#12 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026
  1

• [ROAST][CRITICAL] Dekontaminasi 13-gram untuk utterance intent ≈ tidak ada dekontaminasi

  roastseverity: critical
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#10 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026

• [ROAST][CRITICAL] Ablasi A vs E single-seed, efeknya tenggelam di seed-noise kalian sendiri

  roastseverity: critical
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#7 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026

• [ROAST][CRITICAL] "Augmentation buys transfer" — klaim headline yang tidak pernah diuji

  roastseverity: critical
  Braincore-RnD/Decision-Models-Paper#6 · Filter by author algonacci opened on Oct 13, 2026