Skip to content

SMT Time Series Data: SMC Record incorrectly described as "ordered" #246

Description

@jonaskortner

In Table 3, "Specification of SMC Metadata", SMC Record is described as:

[IRI] https://admin-shell.io/idta/TimeSeries/Record/1/1

preferredName @de: Zeitreihen-Datensatz

preferredName @en: Time series record

definition @de: Ein Zeitreihen-Datensatz ist durch seine ID
innerhalb der Zeitreihe eindeutig und beinhaltet die auf die
ID referenzierten Zeitstempel und Variablenwerte

definition @en: A time series record is unique by its ID
within the time series and contains the timestamps and
variable values referenced to the ID

ordered = true

allowDuplicated = true

However, neither the .aasx file nor a .json export include an "ordered" attribute. Furthermore, to my best understanding of the meta-model, v. 3.1.1, such an attribute doesn't exist. In fact, p. 56 of the Part I of the AAS specification (v. 3.1.1), states:

Note: the elements within a submodel element collection are not ordered. Every element has a unique ID (its
"idShort"). However, it is recommended to adhere to the order defined in the submodel template.

I.e., elements of a SMC cannot be ordered. Hence, the description of SMC Record in the specification document for SMT Time Series Data is misleading and should be deleted.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    IDTA 02008SMT: Time Series DataSMT TIme Series DatabugfixApproved bug fix: creates the bug-fix PR once SMT and version labels are setv1.1SMT version

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions